‘Is the belief that Atlantis was a ‘thought experiment’ written to teach a moral lesson, which was only described in words, and never painted on a vase or carved into a fresco by the ancients, based upon the assumption that Plato’s account of Atlantis was an allegory?’

Posted on by


AI – ‘Yes, this belief is fundamentally based on the scholarly consensus that Plato’s account of Atlantis was a philosophical allegory or “thought experiment”. 

The Allegorical Basis

  • Philosophical Purpose: Scholars argue Plato, a philosopher rather than a historian, used Atlantis to illustrate themes of divine vs. human nature and the corruption of ideal societies.
  • Teaching Tool: The story is seen as a didactic tool meant to contrast a virtuous state (an idealized ancient Athens) with a powerful but morally bankrupt one (Atlantis) to warn against human hubris.
  • Absence in Other Records: No ancient Greek source independent of Plato—including historians like Herodotus or Thucydides—mentions Atlantis or any similar tradition. 

Lack of Visual Evidence

  • No Ancient Art: There is no evidence that Atlantis was ever painted on vases or carved into frescoes by ancient Greeks.
  • Contrast with Myth: Unlike established Greek myths (such as the Titanomachy or the Trojan War), which were frequently depicted in ancient Greek art and architecture, Atlantis remains entirely absent from the visual record of the classical period.
  • Modern Misinterpretation: Popular beliefs that Atlantis was a real, historically recognized place largely began with 19th-century pseudoarchaeology, such as the work of Ignatius L. Donnelly’.