In
Mediation, the possibilities are only limited by the imagination of the
participants and their legal representatives.
Whilst not infinite, in my experience, ‘doable’ deals that ‘are enough’ are
invariably possible.
Negotiation skills are rarely/if at all, taught on undergraduate law courses in
UK universities, or on vocational courses for solicitors and barristers. Those
lawyers who did not study law at university may not even have studied
negotiation skills at all, before entering into private practice at the
coal-face, i.e. the ‘real world’.
I cut my baby teeth negotiating contracts around the world and settling
disputes for Rolls-Royce and Alstom.
As I mentioned to the late Professor Roger Fisher, co-author of ‘Getting to
Yes’, during a short visit to Harvard Law School as a visiting scholar from
King’s College London 23 years ago, I educated myself about commercial
negotiation skills in my early-twenties by reading his books, and then by
applying the principles he wrote about in real life negotiations with a high
degree of success around the world.
At the time as far as I can recall, none of my counter-parts in what are now
BRICS countries e.g. India and China, had read any of his books. That I think
has now changed, and many lawyers in these countries have received a more
thorough grounding in negotiation techniques than most lawyers in the UK have.
That is in large measure attributable to the work of the Standing Conference of
Mediation Advocates (the ‘SCMA’) and my colleague and fellow author Andrew
Goodman.
So, as a result in international commercial negotiation/Mediation Advocacy in a
cross-border dispute, these lawyers have acquired a competitive edge over
solicitors and barristers in the UK.
Critically, and this is the difference, they have probably become more adept
than lawyers in the UK at thinking outside of the box, i.e. at
imaginative/creative problem solving.
Lawyers in the UK need to catch up, otherwise in international
negotiations/cross-border mediations, these BRICS lawyers are going to eat the
City lawyers’ lunch! If as an international law firm you want to survive, this
is no time to be arrogant and complacent.
Negotiation is a skill you develop and perfect by doing.
It requires experimentation and life-long learning.
Mediation Advocacy is a specialised form of negotiation, because it is
facilitated. So, even if you have studied negotiation, then you may still not
know anything at all about Mediation Advocacy. Nor may the partners in your
firm, and your lecturers/tutors at University/on vocational training courses.
This is a massive gap in academic/professional training, i.e. a
‘blind-spot’/potentially existential ‘Achilles heel’ for lawyers in the UK.
To learn more about Mediation Advocacy in estate disputes, see the Slides and
Speaking Notes on the ‘Mediation Advocacy’ page at www.carlislam.co.uk.
Note
the ‘Research Bibliography’ on the ‘Mediation Advocacy’ page at www.carlislam.co.uk & Leathes, Michael
(2017) Negotiation – Things Corporate Counsel Need to Know but Were Not
Taught, Wolters Kluwer.
What I have am still trying to understand is whether this massive oversight by
those who teach law at university in the UK, and on vocational training courses
which are supposed to prepare green initiates for the real world of private
practice, is the result of ‘academic snobbery’ or ignorance. Perhaps it is a
combination of the two?